Founded in 1920, the nber is a private, nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to conducting economic research and to disseminating research findings among academics, public policy makers, and business professionals. Time on the cross the economics of american negro slavery. Their book not only rewrote the history of antebellum slavery, it ushered in a completely new methodology of economic history. Fogel earned his masters degree in economics at columbia university in 1960, learning economics from george stigler. The economics of american negro slavery, written by robert w. Based upon a vast research effort, this volume constitutes an entirely new portrayal of slavery. Slavery, profitability, and the market process mises institute. Asserting that slavery was an economically viable institution that had some benefits for african americans, the book was reprinted in 1995 at its twentieth anniversary. The oxford handbook of slavery in the americas, ed. Contrary to the thinking of the time, he argued that the building of railroads in the united states had contributed far less than had been believed to the overall growth of the economy. Rothbard on the economics of slavery mises institute. The work fogel and engerman presented to their readers is based on quantitative techniques typically associated with computer analysis, otherwise referred to.
The economics of negro slavery is a mythbusting revisionist tour of the reality of slavery as it existed in the american south. Although their study is still based on quantitative analysis of statistical data, it touches on diverse facets of american slavery, including the treatment of slaves, their family lives, and internal stratification within the slave. The most significant recent development in the study of economic history has been the investigation of the profitability of american slavery made famous in robert fogel and stanley engermans time on the cross. Its author, eric williams, later the prime minister of trinidad and tabago, charged that black slavery was the engine that propelled europes rise to global economic dominance. Engerman, generated considerable controversy because it contended that slavery had been a profitable enterprise that had collapsed for politicalrather than economic reasons. Founded in 1920, the nber is a private, nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to conducting economic research and to disseminating research findings among academics, public policy makers, and. In fact, of all the claims contained in time on the cross, these are the two that survived the test of time. The economics of american negro slavery 1974 is a book by the economists robert william fogel and stanley l.
Essentially, it was a criticism of the methodology of the new economic history, or cliometrics, of which conrad and meyer 1958a was the breakthrough application, on the topic of the profitability of slavery. Based upon a vast research effort, this volume constitutes an entirely new portrayal of slavery s past. While some claims especially the one about efficiency survived more or. Solomon northrup 12 years a slave didnt have that to fear when he was kidnapped onto a southern farm. See also engerman, stanley and fogel, robert, the reinterpretation of american economic history new york. Southern cities were small because they failed to develop diversified economies. Fogel and engerman claimed, in their factfilled book, time on the cross, that slavery was economically viable before the civil war and that economic factors would not have brought it down. Economics of american negro slavery table 4 manual occupations in charleston, south carolina, 1848 numbers of. Asserting that economics of american negro slavery series university of michigan the redeemable. Agricultural production based upon slave labor was economically inefficient. The political legacy of american slavery avidit acharya, stanford university matthew blackwell, harvard university maya sen, harvard university we show that contemporary differences in political attitudes across counties in the american south in part trace their origins to slavery. Slavery and scientific management the journal of economic. North studied the link between a market economy and legal and social institutions such as property rights in such works as structure and. Seventeenthcentury planters required field hands to cultivate and harvest cash crops, but had a tiny wage labor force from which to draw.
The economics of american negro slavery 1974 find, read and cite all. The economics of american negro slavery is discussed. The jurisprudence of american slave sales volume 56 issue 1. Apr 02, 2020 the overall effect of slavery on the american economy is also arguable with various scholars identifying some positive and some negative elements of the practice. Massachusetts institute of technology introduction tins study is an investigation of the economics of negro slavery by 1 estimating the rates of return earned by slave capital in the period 1830 through 1860, 2 comparing these returns with those earned. Although their study is still based on quantitative analysis of statistical data, it touches on diverse facets of american slavery, including the treatment of slaves, their. However, one cannot infer that slavery made america richer from them.
Jan 03, 2003 how slavery helped build a world economy. North of the 1993 nobel prize in economics for having renewed research in economic history by applying economic theory and quantitative methods in order to explain economic and institutional change. The work fogel and engerman presented to their readers is based on quantitative techniques typically associated with computer analysis, otherwise referred to as cliometrics. Few works of history have exerted as powerful an influence as a book published in 1944 called capitalism and slavery. This pdf is a selection from an outofprint volume from. An overviewforced labor was an essential component of the southern economy from the time europeans first settled the american south in significant numbers.
Robert william fogel american economist britannica. The economics of american negro slavery, 18301860 robert evans, jr. In time on the cross 1974, fogel used statistical analysis to examine the relationship between the politics of american slavery and its profitability. It appears to be an unpublished communication concerning an article and comment that appeared in the journal of political economy.
The time on the cross americas experience with black slavery was only about 250 years or 350 if you include the spanish colonies. Enslaving indians to meet their labor needs proved to be an unsuccessful. The actual period for the kind of slavery that most think of when they think of southern plantations is shorter yet. Aug 21, 2019 the other two facts that slavery was immensely profitable and that slave productivity increased are not debated. That same year, wilmington, north carolinas largest city, had just 7,264 inhabitants. The economics of american negro slavery 9780316287005 by fogel, robert william.
Atlantic slaverys impact on european and british economic. The jurisprudence of american slave sales the journal of. This pdf is a selection from an outofprint volume from the. The economics of american negro slavery 1974 is a book by the economists robert fogel and stanley l. The rise and fall of american slavery, 2 volumes, 1989, isbn 9780393312195. Coclanis writing on the economics of slavery is in some ways an impossibly difficult task, for the.
However, by 1400 slavery had long disappeared from europe, which motivated the european search for a supply of forced. That complexity has influenced the subsequent writings of fogel and engerman but in time on the cross they summarized it in five main propositions. The economics of slavery like other slave societies, the south did not produce urban centers on a scale equal with those in the north. Forced labor was an essential component of the southern economy from the time europeans first settled the american south in significant numbers. Slavery provided extremely harsh material conditions for the typical slave. Oct 17, 2012 robert fogel and stanley engermans time on the cross. The economics of american slavery by robert william fogel, stanley l. Rothbards writings and the revolution in the subject matter that was taking place at the time it. Slavery was already present in africa before the slave trades and in fact continues, in some parts of the continent, to the present day. The problem of s m western culture by david brion davis. The economics of american negro slavery, which he wrote with stanley l.
Virginias largest city, richmond, had a population of just 15,274 in 1850. Slavery and the cliometric revolution the international context of u. The economics of american negro slavery by robert william fogel and stanley l. The slavery system in the united states was a national system that touched the very core of its economic and political life. The economics of american negro slavery 1995 description economists robert fogel and stanly engerman take a financial look at the practice of slavery. First published in 1974, fogel and engermans groundbreaking book reexamined the economic foundations of american slavery, marking the start of a new period of slavery scholarship and some searching revisions of a national tradition c.
Fogel and engerman also claimed that slavery was efficient, although other economic. Apr 12, 2014 the 10point summary of time on the cross. Engerman hardcover book, 336 pages see other available editions description time on the cross is at once a jarring attack on the methods and conclusions of traditional scholarship and a lucid, highly readable analysis of the special american problem black slavery. Murray rothbard wrote an unpublished note in the early 1960s on the economics of antebellum slavery. The economics of american negro slavery, 2 volumes, 1974. It challenges traditional assumptions about the material condition and management of slaves, their work habits, domestic welfare, and the. Was slavery the engine of american economic growth. Explaining the relative efficiency of slave agriculture in the antebellum south. Oxford university press, 2010 the economics of slavery peter a.
There had been all sorts of slavery all over the world since the binning of the neolithic period six thousand years earlier. The economics of american negro slavery, by robert w. The political legacy of american slavery avidit acharya, stanford university matthew blackwell, harvard university maya sen, harvard university we show that contemporary differences in political attitudes across counties in the american south in part trace their origins to slavery s prevalence more than 150 years ago. Evidence and methodsa supplement, by robert will the main themes of time on the cross are already familiar. Robert fogel and stanley engermans time on the cross. The south did not make the same technological and industrial advancements as the north until after slavery had been abolished, and some scholars consider this to have been an economic. The economics of american negro slavery the economics of american negro slavery. Occupations male slaves free negroes white males domestics 1,188 9 cooks and confectioners 7 18 0 fruiterers and peddlers 0 6 46 gardeners 3 0 5 coachmen 15 4 2 draymen 67 11 porters 35 5 8 stevedores 2 1 21 pilots and sailors 50 1 176 fishermen 11 14 10. Engerman, american journal of sociology 81 march 1976. The economics of american negro slavery, volumes 1 and 2.
Slavery as an economic institution was economically moribund. Rhode, biological innovation and productivity growth in the antebellum cotton economy, journal of economic history, v. This book, originally published in 1974 by little, brown and company, is a sweeping reexamination of the economic foundations of american negro slavery. This detailed analysis of slavery in the antebellum south was written in 1975 in response to the prior years publication of robert fogel and stanley engermans controversial time on the cross, which argued that slavery was an efficient and dynamic engine for the southern economy and that its success was due largely to the willing cooperation of the slaves themselves. John anthony scott historians, until quite recently, have portrayed the american south during the antebellum period as a moribund society on the verge of disin. Slavery, profitability, and the market process mises. Included as a reference for the blogpost baptism by blood cotton. Robert fogel and stanley engerman, time on the cross.
8 1598 870 1221 977 347 598 61 1060 696 1065 263 1119 1445 448 1146 1162 274 1130 1185 1370 238 1275 1200 1515 1002 57